There is a
challenge hidden in the publicity, excitement and
enthusiasm that is created when the technological
geniuses give birth to an even better computer, an
even faster communication system, or an even smaller
machine to fit into the living room. The challenge
is whether or not the integrity of the home can be
maintained. The electronic baby is born, and in many
cases it has been brought home. Can it be
incorporated in a way that will enrich us all or
will it demand, in the way that babies often do, 100
per cent attention. lt has been recognised over the
past thirty years or so that people cope better with
change if they are prepared for it. Couples seek out
childbirth classes when they are pregnant, but how
many seek help for the birth and integration into
the home of the Electronic baby. However, some
couples are seeking help for problems that stem from
the more flexible ways of working that are now
possible because of new technology. As more women
are working, as less and less security is possible
in the work place, as greater and greater demands
are made from those in work, the stress of the
information society is being seen reflected in
peoples' relationships.
The rapid and
relentless move into the technological age has
helped to create a fantasy of a society where
anything is possible. Theoretically we can work
anywhere and have access to information from all
over the world. Fuelling the belief that anything is
possible, a whole universe can be created of
whatever we desire. A universe called virtual
reality, seducing the computer operator into
believing that it is an actual reality. For some who
are robust enough to embrace the challenge of the
information society this is an exhilarating time -
the sky is the limit, but where will the boundaries
be in this world of limitless possibilities, and who
will draw them?
Teleworking, or
working at home is being seen by many as an
economically and environmentally sound thing to do.
A new way of working allowing for more freedom and
more flexibility. This must be true. Since the
industrial revolution men have left home early in
the morning returning often eight or nine hours
later; neither he nor his family have given a
passing thought to what the other has been doing all
day. During the past fifteen years or so it has
become common-place for women also to leave the
house in order to work. The home has become a place
where people have gathered after the days work has
been done. But with the move to working from home
all this is changing.
This paper explores
why this quiet revolution needs to be taken
seriously from psychological point of view. Working
at home is not a new innovation, fifty years ago
many people worked at home; Doctors, Dentists,
Farmers, Solicitors and others, and today many
writers and academics work at home. However with the
introduction of technology subtle but important
differences arise.
The teleworker
works not only at home, but also from home. For
example John works from home, Mary works at home,
there is a difference. Clients come to see Mary and
she offers them her skills as a Chiropodist in her
small consulting room in the garden. When her day is
over, or when she has a short break during the day
she walks over the house and leaves her workplace
behind. Of course she is sometimes preoccupied with
thoughts about a client, but mostly she is able to
contain her work to the consulting room. It is,
however, different for John who teleworks. He is
able to relate through the various technological
appliances to the whole world. Although physically
at home, the teleworker's attention could be
anywhere.
Wired to a network
that spans the world, ideas and thoughts are
transmitted at speed of light, responses cascade
from the Fax machine and flit across the computer
screen. The telephone no longer has to be left in
the office in order to make a coffee, it can be
carried conveniently in the pocket, so that no calls
need go unanswered. No one has to know that you need
to eat or drink or defecate. Time is no longer a
barrier to communication. Always ready to receive,
the faithful Fax will spew out it's messages any
time during day or night. The answer machine will
record the messages from different time zones
allowing you to reply whilst the rest of the country
sleeps. E-mail collects the messages which wait
reproachfully for acknowledgement. There is no
longer for the Teleworker such a thing as a natural
break. In this exciting world we now inhabit, there
is a catch. When do we say, 'enough is enough', how
do we say 'I'm off duty'?
Home means
different things to different people, but whatever
the culture, there is a shared belief about homes
and families. These beliefs may differ from country
to country, but we do all have expectations of
partners and children. Many of these expectations
are unspoken - even unconscious. For the most part
it has been assumed that whatever the difficulties
encountered when working from home, there will be no
emotional or domestic difficulties. The human
element is taken for granted and yet when the
Tavistock Institute of Human Relations made a
Pan-European study of the possibility of working
from home (Holti - Tavistock Publications, 1988) Dr.
Richard Holti wrote that 'the only obstacle to
working from home would be the Psychological one'.
The work-place is
an institution, but so is the home an institution.
Each has its own rules and values, both spoken and
unspoken. Some of these rules and values are common
to us all, but many are unique to a particular
office or factory or home. Most workplaces will take
care to inform its new employees of its culture, and
what isn't formally stated will become quickly
apparent when some mistake or other is made, i.e. it
might be quite all right in some offices to make
private phone calls, in another it may be stated
clearly that speaking to friends on the Telephone is
out of the question. Having worked in the same place
for some time it will become clear how much leeway
can be taken. The culture will gradually be made
known. It may not be obvious how the culture
developed, but the 'how' of it is not terribly
important unless a sociological study is being
carried out. The employee is there to fit into an
existing organization. The ambition to change it may
come later, but unless the remit is to examine the
organization in order to do that, initially at
least, he or she will abide by the rules.
Yet when the
workplace is the home, when the distance in question
is from the office not from the family - who is to
fit in with whom? After all, home is also an
institution. It also has its spoken and unspoken
rules. lt also has a culture. However it is doubtful
that there are any written memos to spell these
rules out. It is unlikely that anyone has an
understanding of the history of the culture. There
will however be an unspoken or unconscious
expectation that however large the initial
disruption, the home will be able to accommodate and
absorb the intrusion and change.
This quiet
revolution has been led by technology and business.
The Economics of Teleworking (Noel Hodson, 1993) is
full of hard facts. There are statistics to call on
and Balance Sheets to back-up findings. But when
thinking about the affects on the family and
relationships there are no hard facts, no statistics
to measure the emotional impact of the home becoming
the work place. Nevertheless there is a need to
analyse the emotional Balance Sheet, and a necessity
for all those concerned in instituting this
fundamental change to pay as much attention to the
psychological needs as to the business and
technological needs.
The following two
cases illustrate some of the difficulties that can
happen when it is taken for granted that home will
absorb these new working habits without any
preparation at all.
The Fax at
Midnight
For some time
Robert and Susan had been arguing about everything.
They realised that life had become more stressful
since Robert had decided to work from home, but were
bewildered as they had both made the decision to
take up his company's offer of the opportunity to
work from home. Robert's company were relocating its
workforce from the centre of London to an area about
a hundred miles away and some of the employees had
been given the choice to move with the company or to
work from home. Robert and Susan felt flattered to
be given this choice and felt that if Robert worked
from home it would give them more flexibility.
They couldn't
understand what had gone wrong. It seemed as if
there was no emotional space for them to think about
what might be the problem and they also felt
humiliated that they weren't coping. The company had
made no provision for any domestic problems to be
aired - there was a computer helpline in case any of
the machines Robert had come home armed with went
wrong, and an arrangement had been made for him and
others in the same position to spend a day a month
in the central office so that he didn't feel
isolated from the company. But it hadn't so it
seemed crossed anyone's mind that there would be
problems at home. Of course this belief reflected
Robert and Susans conviction that as a happy couple
and secure family they could only befit from
spending more time together.
The incident that
convinced Robert and Susan that they needed help
happened at midnight. Bob had converted the loft
space over the garage to an office which was reached
from the landing. The company had equipped it with a
photocopier, a separate Telephone line and a Fax
machine. The situation that brought them to
counselling was that Robert had wandered into his
office on his way to bed.
There was a Fax in the machine from America and
within seconds he was absorbed in it. Susan who was
waiting in the bedroom suddenly realised that Robert
wasn't in the bathroom that he was in fact involved
with work. She became absolutely furious, they had a
terribly row and unable to resolve it they decided
to seek help.
What emerged from
their first interview was that they were having to
deal with a major life change. The structure and
routine of their lives had been completely changed,
but there were no guidelines, worse than that no one
believed, not even them, that they were having to
deal with anything difficult at all. When it was
suggested that perhaps they were both finding their
new way of life a strain there was an audible sigh
of relief.
Robert was an only
child, born to an elderly couple. He learnt when he
was very young to be independent and self sufficient,
and was happy to spend time on his own. In fact,
Robert's parents had taken little interest in his
school work or career, and were more likely to
criticise than admire his work.
Susan came from a
very different family. Her parents had a farm. Susan
was the eldest of four children. All the children
were expected to help on the farm and work together
to make it a success. Her father was very definitely
the head of the family and commanded respect and
some fear from the children, but the over all
picture of her family was of a large noisy busy
group of people all working together.
The different
experiences that Susan and Robert had when growing
up meant that they both had had very different
expectations of what it would be like when Robert
came home to work. It became clear that they each
hoped for different things when they decided to
accept the offer Robert's company had made. Susan
had a picture in her mind of the sort of family she
grew up in. With Robert in the house all day it
would be she hoped like the noisy busy family of her
childhood. Robert on the other hand expected quite
the opposite. He saw himself working quietly in his
office left alone to get on with his work in the way
he had done when he was living with his parents.
Susan and Robert
became disappointed. When Susan made efforts to
create the situation she had dreamed of, and tried
to include Robert in family life or join in with
what he was doing. Robert was reminded of his
critical mother and became even more determined to
keep his work away from the family. When Robert
became angry and remote, it reminded Susan of the
worst aspects of her authoritarian father.
Once Susan and
Robert realised that they were each trying to
recreate old patterns of living, they were less
angry with each other and could begin to think of
ways in which they could create a shared pattern, so
that Robert's new way of working could really
benefit them all.
The Human
Baby
The second case is
a young couple who sought help after their Doctor
recognised Jane's symptoms of not sleeping or eating
properly, and constant irritability as stress. As
these symptoms stemmed from the time Jane began
working from home, it was decided that both she and
her husband needed help with dealing with their new
Situation.
Jane and Phillip
had been very excited when Jane managed to negotiate
with her ex-employers to take up her job as a
designer for them again but to do most of the work
from home. They had a child of two and a half and
had really missed Jane's income over the past three
years.
The spoken hopes of
Jane and Phillip were that they would be able to
manage to combine two things: To provide the sort of
childhood for their daughter that both of them had
enjoyed, a warm family home with a mother who was
always there, whilst they both continued their
careers which they loved. They thought carefully
about how they would manage. Phillip's job would
allow him some flexibility. Jane's Mother was
willing to help and they felt that if they had an
au-pair and all pulled together, things would
probably work out well.
Within a month it
felt as if something was wrong. Jane was exhausted.
She felt as if she wasn't doing anything adequately.
Although she was working from morning 'till night
she felt guilty both about her job and her daughter.
Phillip and her mother were both doing their best to
help but her daughter wasn't, she clearly hadn't
been involved at the planning stage of the new
development in her family, and she wasn't about to
be co-operative. She couldn't understand why if her
mother was in the house she didn't come to her when
she cried. The au-pair did her best but she wasn't
the real thing. Jane found it very difficult to
ignore Jo's cries when she was just a room away. She
also found it impossible to have a coffee break
without fulfilling some domestic need at the same
time, such as filling or emptying the washing
machine, or cheering up the au-pair, or making up
for the time she wasn't with Jo by reading her a
quick story. This of course meant that her own paid
work got pushed into the evenings and she was often
to be found at her desk late at night. She was doing
two jobs for the price of one.
Once again, both
Phillip and Jane were relieved when they defined the
problem. They both realised that until Jo went to
school, it was going to be really hard work to
manage the sort of home life they both wanted for
themselves and their daughter, but felt it was worth
trying to resolve the problems in order to avoid an
all day nursery for Jo. 'It would all be so simple',
they said, 'if there had been the same advancements
in human babies as there had been in
Technical babies', but it seemed the human model
hadn't made any advances at all. They needed as much
attention as they ever had done.
Jane's Problem was
helped by structuring a timetable. She goes to her
office early in the morning whilst Phillip gets Jo
up, dresses her and gives her breakfast. He then
leaves for his office mid morning and Jane allows
herself to spend most of the day 'at home'. She
works again for three hours in the evening when Jo
is in bed. The au-pair and her mother are necessary
back ups, and bridge the gaps, but they don't have
to be alternative parents. This isn't a perfect
solution to Jane and Phillip's problem, but they
feel that it is good enough for the time being.
These two cases
highlighting many of the issues that need to be
explored when someone is considering working at or
from home.
Territorial Rights
When the home is
invaded by the wage earner, how is the invasion of
time and space negotiated? In the first case,
neither Robert or Susan nor Robert's Employer had
thought it necessary to take into account the impact
on the home of Robert going home to work. The
territory which for years had been Susan's by day
now had to be shared between them. Susan wanted
Robert to share the space, but she wanted him to
share the space in her way. Robert did not think it
was necessary to take Susan's needs into account. He
moved in, defined his territory, didn't want it
invaded and got very cross when he was reminded that
he was now at home.
Boundaries
When there is an
office to go to, the boundaries are define
automatically, the Telephone calls and the Fax's are
confined to the desk. There is some advantage to the
commute in that work problems can be left behind,
and home can offer a welcome relief and fresh
perspective on the days' events. When the boundaries
are not automatic, a new and deliberate protocol
must be negotiated with all concerned. The Fax at
midnight was an intrusion into a space and a
breaking of a boundary that would have been
unthinkable a few years ago. It's like having your
Boss in the bedroom. Absolutely terrible for the
Libido.
Are
Electronic Babies more advanced than Human Babies?
When Phillip and
Jane joked about the electronic baby being more
advanced than their daughter, they had identified
one of the difficulties that we are all having to
deal with, as this technological revolution drives
us all on. Technology made it possible for Jane to
work at home and be near her daughter. She didn't
have to make the choice she would have done ten
years ago between staying at home or going out to
work, but she needed to be made aware that it was
very difficult for Jo to have a mother visible but
unavailable. This isn't only the case for babies
either. Many husbands and wives reflect on their
disappointment when the person returning home to
work seemed as remote as they were when they worked
away from home.
Communicating with the Family and the World
This paper began
with a challenge to this new way of working. Can
working from home be a new way of working or is it
going to be an old way of working in a different
place and with new technology? Will the home and
work-place be able to be integrated or will one try
to dominate the other? There is little use in being
able to communicate with the world if we cannot hear
what those nearest to us are saying. In order for
this aspect of the quiet revolution to gain the
attention it deserves, these questions need to be
asked and taken into consideration. Traditionally
the home has been expected to contain all the
stresses and strains that life has to offer. lt is
expected that it will accommodate the different
demands that society imposes on it in each
generation. But home is only as robust and flexible
as the people in it can allow it to be.
The Electronic baby
is born. We need to pay it attention and to find a
way of saying 'no' occasionally to the greater and
greater possibilities it offers us. We need to help
it to find its place in the family. lf we don't, it
will, like neglected babies do, dominate our lives.
|